I did try and clean the partitions using the link and I managed to get all 4 disks initialized, so thank you very much for your help.
Unfortunately, I still couldn't get a raid 5 volume created no matter which option I tried. I even tried creating a simple volume, no raid, with just 2 disks but still get the same error - failed to apply settings. I used both the automatic options and manual options but couldn't create any volumes.
Maybe I'm missing a step?